arXiv:2610.11028 · v3
Synchronization Reveals Market Structure That Classical Randomness Tests Cannot Detect
摘要
Whether asset prices contain structure beyond a random walk is classically assessed with variance-ratio tests of the random-walk hypothesis. Synchronization measures from physics, notably the Kuramoto order parameter applied across trading timescales, have been proposed as an alternative diagnostic of market state, but they have been validated on single asset classes and never compared with the variance-ratio test on the same data. We compute a cross-timeframe Kuramoto coherence measure and a heteroskedasticity-robust Lo-MacKinlay variance ratio on identical windows for 61 instruments spanning cryptocurrencies, foreign exchange, metals, equity indices and single-name equities. The two diagnostics are statistically independent. We explain this analytically: coherence decomposes exactly into a direction-agreement channel and a volatility-agreement channel, and under sign-symmetric returns the direction channel is independent of the variance ratio and of every other statistic built from squared returns; simulations confirm the prediction. Coherence tracks the directional cleanliness of recent price moves in all five asset classes, whereas the variance-ratio test cannot reject the random walk for most of the panel. Held to finance benchmarks with strict information timing, however, coherence adds almost nothing to heterogeneous autoregressive volatility forecasts out of sample, and trading rules built on it earn no gross return outside cryptocurrency, where trading the coherence direction at high coherence breaks even at about five basis points per round trip. Failing to reject weak-form efficiency therefore does not rule out directional structure, but the structure that synchronization reveals is mostly descriptive and economically thin.
作者备注:33 pages, 7 figures, 6 tables. v3: adds out-of-sample HAR baselines and an economic-value analysis, uses closed-bar information timing, and corrects forecast statistics affected by opening-time alignment of multi-timeframe data. Submitted to The North American Journal of Economics and Finance