GroundWork:通过结构化论证模型连接人类与LLM推理
GroundWork: Bridging Human and LLM Reasoning Through a Structured Argumentation Model
Sjoerd Vink, Byungmoo Kim, Michael Behrisch, Adam Coscia, Remco Chang
AI 速读 基于摘要
GroundWork将Toulmin论证模型实现为人类与LLM共享、可编辑的类型化图结构,使基于来源的论证可检查、可比较、可修订。
cs.HC
查看原文摘要
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into workflows that require reasoning over text documents, yet interaction remains largely conversational. This leaves argumentative structure implicit or embedded in text, making it difficult to maintain, compare, and revise arguments as analyses evolve. We present GroundWork, a mixed-initiative system that makes argument structure a shared, editable state for humans and LLMs. GroundWork operationalizes the Toulmin model of argumentation as a typed graph with explicit operations for human and LLM edits. It exposes this structure through coordinated corpus views and an editable workbench for constructing, comparing, testing, and tracing source-grounded arguments. We evaluate GroundWork through an expert study with four participants spanning consulting, product development, law, and immunology, and three use-case scenarios in intelligence, law, and medicine. Our findings show that GroundWork makes source-grounded arguments inspectable, comparable, and revisable as shared human-LLM state.