成熟度²:评估密码敏捷性成熟度模型的成熟度
Maturity$^2$: Assessing the Maturity of Crypto Agility Maturity Models
Leonie Wolf, Robin Leander Schröder, Sebastian Schinzel, Fabian Ising
AI 速读 基于摘要
作者依据既有设计原则评估三个业界驱动的密码敏捷性成熟度模型,发现其普遍缺乏可测量、可复现的评估标准与改进指导。
cs.CR
查看原文摘要
Crypto agility maturity models aim to support organizations in preparing for cryptographic transitions, such as migrating to post-quantum cryptography. Recognizing the importance of measurable maturity, NIST references several such models in its guidance. Given NIST's influence on cybersecurity practice, these models may shape organizational planning and governance mechanisms. However, their design quality has not been systematically evaluated. In this work, we assess three industry-driven maturity models against established design principles. Our analysis reveals recurring weaknesses, particularly the lack of measurable, reproducible assessment criteria and limited prescriptive guidance for improving crypto agility. At the same time, we highlight individual strengths that can assist practitioners in choosing among the models and derive concrete recommendations for strengthening future crypto agility maturity models.