arXiv:2605.01337 · v2
Comparison of OpenAlex and Scopus coverage of German institutions' publications in top-tier journals
摘要
OpenAlex has recently emerged as a leading alternative to proprietary bibliometric sources. However, concerns remain regarding the quality of its metadata, especially the institutional profiles which are crucial for evaluating organizations. This study assesses the quality of affiliation data in OpenAlex using German research institutions. Publications from top-tier journals were analyzed and institutional publication counts in OpenAlex were systematically compared with counts in Scopus. The results show that OpenAlex generally contains more publications at the journal level, reflecting its broader coverage. However, institutional publication counts in OpenAlex are consistently lower; it contained 6.8% fewer institution-paper links in the analyzed sample. Aggregate institutional counts nevertheless showed very high rank correlation and concordance with Scopus. Discrepancies varied substantially across fields, publishers and journals. Detailed investigation identified missing affiliation information, differences in institutional boundaries, and divergent year and journal assignments, while errors present in both databases. These findings suggest that OpenAlex is suitable for comparative institutional analyses in academic research but requires further improvement in affiliation metadata before it can be used for evaluation contexts that rely on absolute publication counts.
作者备注:revised and expanded. earlier version was presented at STI 2026 and published in: De Parade, I., Vandewalle, E., & Engels, T. C. E. (2026, August 10). STI-ENID 2026 Conference Proceedings. 30th Annual International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators (STI-ENID 2026), University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium